Skip to main content

David Walsh thinks that Contador cheated

They're all cheats. They're all dopers. 

That's the position of David Walsh, the author From Lance to Landis: Inside the American Doping Controversy at the Tour de France. In his latest screed, he claims that Alberto Contador, the winner of this year's Tour de France must be a cheat. 

Why? 

He climbed the Col d'Aubisque faster than Lance Armstrong did. 

Hmmm. Interesting logic.

Let me start off by saying that, yes, there were definitely cheaters in this year's Tour. Some of them got caught, and others probably got away with it. 

Walsh previously stated that Lance was doping throughout his seven Tour wins. With all of the testing that stage winners and race leaders undergo. That would make Lance the luckiest man in the world. 

So... let's look at some of his possible thought patterns.  

Lance cheated and Contador cheated. Contador was faster. Contador must have had better drugs than Lance did.

Or... It's been two years now since Lance won the Tour and I still haven't been able to definitively prove that he cheated. Now, Contador has come along and he was faster than Lance. Is Walsh now saying that Lance didn't cheat and Contador did? That means that he has to acknowledge that his book is utter bullshit. 

If Lance did not cheat, and others did while he was racing, does that mean that he was such an incredible physical specimen that he didn't need to cheat?

If Lance didn't cheat and Contador didn't cheat, does that mean that Contador is physically stronger than Lance ever was?

Here's my take: Both men were tested. Neither was found to be cheating. If we are saying that the tests are definite (and I think that we must), you have to look at other factors:
  • Equipment: The UCI weight limit for bikes has not changed, but the bike companies continue to innovate. Frame weights may be similar, but they have learned how to make them both stiffer and more comfortable. Less energy wasted and less fatique. Also, you can't dismiss innovations in wheels and cranksets. Less rotational weight means that you expend less energy getting the bicycle up to speed and keeping it there.
  • Weather: How hot & humid was it during Lance's rides? How hot & humid was it this year? What's the tolerance level of each for the weather? 
  • Mental toughness: Lance was acknowledged to be a fierce competitor. There's no question about that. Contador is relatively young and unknown. He could be tougher than anyone knows. Climbers are a different sort. 
I know this has been a bit of a brain dump. I hate to give this guy anymore publicity than he already has, but I think that professional journalists, such as Walsh, should be held to some degree of integrity and proof. 


Popular posts from this blog

Even More From Eurobike, courtesy of Velonews

I just received a number of Eurobike Exhibition updates from Velonews.com These are dated throughout the exhibition.  August 31 : Giant rolls out refinements to their Maestro line of suspension bikes Ridley introduces an entry-level carbon fiber cyclocross bike Only cosmetic changes for Scott's road bikes, but new mountain and cyclocross bikes A new mountain/cyclocross pedal from Look New pedals, headsets, cranks and wheels from Crank Brothers A redesign of RockShox's SID fork for it's 10th anniversary September 1 : New clinchers from Lightweight A new line of cycling shorts and bibs from Assos Super light Nano Gram Zero pedals from Speedplay A new range of suspension forks from Maverick A little more about Selle Italia's new saddles with Troy Lee as well as a new Team Edition Flite model New white bars, stems and seatposts from FSA. Also, new compact shapes in the Plasma bar/stem combo and the K-Wing carbon bar, a new crankset, a K-Force tubular wheelset and an integra...

Vuelta Stage 11 plus other news

Vuelta de Espana - Stage 11: The day started with a two man breakaway at the 8km mark that saw it's biggest gap at the 40km point. The peloton was taking it easy, working only hard enough to let the break not get any bigger.  At 120km, the peloton started to reel in the break and they had made up the 3 minute advantage by km 150.   The Milram and Lampre-Fondital teams, along with Rabobank, did the majority of the work to make up the break. By the final 10 km, the speeds racked up considerably, with T-Mobile & Milram leading a long, single file peloton.  Milram took over the lead in the final 2 kilometers. Zabel did the work to set up Pettachi to take the final sprint at the last corner. Pettachi racks up his 18th career win today at the Vuelta.  coming by teammate Erik Zabel in the final meters of today's stage. Paolo Bettini took second, Zabel third.  The G.C. stays much the same with Menchov, Efimkin, Evans, Sastre and Miquez in the Top 5 spots.  Other News: Ivan Dominque...

Landis at the Shenandoah Mountain 100

Some of you probably took advantage of the long Labor Day weekend to take a long bike ride (not me, I had a nasty cold).  Floyd Landis took a long ride, too, participating in the Shenandoah Moutain 100 .  Reports are that he got to the race early, hung out with the locals , chewed the fat , had some beer and signed some autographs. He hung around after the race as well. Somewhere in the middle of all of that, he got third place in a very tough race.  I have to agree with Harlan Price (who took 2nd place at the SM100) that Floyd must love the sport if he keeps showing up at events like Leadville and Shenanhoah Mountain. Maybe he picks up a little bit of press coverage, but these are fringe events that the mainstream media largely ignore. Some may say that he is schmoozing fans, but that's not going to help his trial end in his favor.  Sounds to me like he's just an ordinary guy who loves to ride hard and party hard afterwards. He hasn't gone into hiding, he's up front,...